top of page
  • X
  • Youtube

J.J. McCarthy

Michigan

J.J. McCarthy

HT:

6030

WT:

219

YR:

JR

POS:

QB

OVR RK

6

POS RK

CEILING POTENTIAL

2

High-End Starter Potential

OVR RK

PLAYSTYLE & SCHEME FIT

McCarthy plays in a pro-style system, showcasing a balanced mix of pocket presence and mobility. He's suitable for schemes prioritizing a mobile pocket passer with the flexibility to make plays off-script. Best fit for teams using a Shanahan/Payton style offense that leverages his intermediate/short passing game strength and can develop his processing skills.

CEILING GRADE ANALYSIS

High-End Starter Potential (65-69)
A player expected to become a top-tier starter within their first few years. They possess strong physical tools and good technical skills but may have some limitations in their game. With development, they can reach near-elite levels and provide consistent impact at their position.

Primary scout:

Brandon Lundberg

KEY STRENGTHS

Accuracy On The Move

High-Velocity Throws

Clutch Ability

KEY WEAKNESSES

Improve Deep Accuracy

Trust Your Structure

Can Force Throws

PLAYER COMPARISONS

Joe Burrow

Alex Smith

Chad Pennington

Where Ty Simpson Ranks in the 2026 QB Class (Moore & Mendoza)
bottom of page