J.J. McCarthy
QB
Michigan
HT:
6030
WT:
219
YR:
JR
NO:
9
OVR RK
6
POS RK
CEILING POTENTIAL
2
Near Elite
OVR RK
SCOUTING REPORT
McCarthy's growth since arriving at the University of Michigan is one of the primary reasons NFL scouts and GMs are enamored. McCarthy has a powerful arm; he can make any throw at any level of the field. His mobility allows him to create as a runner and a passer, similar to Drake Maye and Caleb Williams. His ceiling, combined with his competitive nature and willingness to grind nonstop, has earned him the number two spot in my QB rankings.
Primary scout:
Brandon Lundberg
PLAYSTYLE & SCHEME FIT
McCarthy plays in a pro-style system, showcasing a balanced mix of pocket presence and mobility. He's suitable for schemes prioritizing a mobile pocket passer with the flexibility to make plays off-script. Best fit for teams using a Shanahan/Payton style offense that leverages his intermediate/short passing game strength and can develop his processing skills.
KEY STRENGTHS
Accuracy On The Move
High-Velocity Throws
Clutch Ability
KEY WEAKNESSES
Improve Deep Accuracy
Trust Your Structure
Can Force Throws
PLAYER COMPARISONS
Joe Burrow
Alex Smith
Chad Pennington