J.J. McCarthy is a promising quarterback prospect out of Michigan, displaying impressive arm strength, good mobility, and a high football IQ. He can throw the ball with power and precision from the pocket or on the move, where he has made some big-time off-platform throws. However, there are areas for improvement, particularly concerning his inconsistency in accuracy, pocket presence, and decision-making about when to pass or run. Despite these areas of development, McCarthy's raw potential suggests he could become a starting quarterback in the NFL. His blend of physical skills, mental acumen, and leadership abilities could position him to make a significant impact at the professional level.